The LWF Blog
Fire Engineering for design | Water Mist Fire Protection in the UKOctober 10, 2013 10:32 am
When considering methods of fire suppression, water mist systems offer certain benefits to building designers and end user occupiers, but gaining approval for the installation can be an issue. With a distinct lack of firm design and installation standards, how can you be sure that the system installation will meet the requirements of the approvals authority?
This article will discuss the considerations that should be given to the specification when considering a water mist system.
Advantages of Water Mist
The use of water mist systems in the UK has increased over the last decade for a number of reasons, the advantages being:
- Non toxic
- No asphyxiation risk
- Environmental friendly problems
- Limited damage to properties
What is Water Mist?
A water mist fire protection system is a fixed active fire protection system that discharges a fine spray of small water droplets. The water droplets remove the heat from the fire (cooling of fire plume and wetting/cooling of the fuel surface), displaces oxygen and dilutes the fuel vapour from the fire, resulting in fire suppression or extinguishment. The term ‘water mist’ refers to fine water sprays in which the drop diameter, (DV0,90) is less than 1mm measured in a plane 1m from the nozzle at its minimum operating pressure.
Sprinkler Systems Vs Water Mist Systems
The application of sprinkler systems is largely understood and there are historic performance records for buildings. Sprinkler systems have standards and approvals for the components and the design and installation. For these reasons sprinkler systems are accepted as automatic fire suppression systems in the current Building Regulations in the UK.
A frequently asked question from building control professionals and fire safety officers is whether a water mist system can achieve an equivalent level of performance compared to a sprinkler system. Unfortunately, there is no straight answer to this, as water mist systems are not designed in the same way as sprinkler systems. The use of water mist systems for volume protection in buildings is largely unproven. To date there appear to have been very few reported fire events in buildings with water mist systems. As the water droplets produced by a water mist system are smaller than for sprinklers it is considered that a significant amount of the water mist droplets can be ‘blown away’ under certain conditions such as open doors or windows. As a result, the water coverage flux density at the fire location is reduced by ventilation. However, there is also empirical test evidence which shows that, within a small compartment, water mist performed well in a fully sealed enclosure.
Ventilation and compartment sizes are merely two examples from many critical design details that can affect the successful operation of a water mist system. In order to use water mist systems as an alternative to sprinkler systems it is a requirement within the Building Regulations that such systems have been designed and tested for use in buildings and are fit for their intended purpose.
Currently there is no published British Standard for water mist systems or water mist system components. Existing water mist standards such as the published National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) 750 Standard on Water Mist Fire Protection Systems or International Maritime Organisation (IMO) Standards are not directly applicable to UK land-based applications. A European water mist (Technical Specification CEN TS 14972) has been published which includes a fire performance test for various applications. However this document has not been adopted in the UK and its suitability for UK application is uncertain.
Two new Drafts for Development were issued in October 2010:
DD 8489: Fixed fire protection systems – Industrial and commercial water mist systems
DD 8458: Fixed fire protection systems – Residential and domestic water mist systems
There is currently insufficient technical data available for them to be published as full British Standards. These documents try to define the testing protocols for water mist systems in various different applications; however, they do not cover all water mist scenarios. It is anticipated that tests for further applications will be developed in due course and published in additional sections, as the specification for fire performance tests is developed for other uses.
Due to the limitation of guidance on water mist systems, extra care should be taken when choosing a water mist system for buildings in the UK.
Acceptability of Water Mist Systems
In the absence of a generalised design and installation standard, the acceptability of water mist system installations for buildings will depend on demonstration of their effectiveness in a suitable fire performance test, relevant to the real life application.
To choose an acceptable water mist system, it is imperative that relevant supporting evidence be made available by the supplier or installer, demonstrating that test fires have been satisfactorily extinguished, suppressed or controlled (whichever is the desired result from the system) in rooms of the same size and same occupancy, with an equivalent fire load as the intended application. In other words, water mist systems for buildings should be considered on a case-by-case basis to determine whether a proposed system has met the fire protection objectives.
As water mist does not primarily extinguish by direct wetting of solid fuels, its impact on deep-seated fires will be slow. Other scenarios where water mist may not be able to extinguish fires include small fires and shielded fires. For this reason, the fire protection objectives for a water mist system need to be clearly stated by the supplier or installer with supporting evidence, so that the building control professionals and fire safety officers can make a judgement about the acceptability of water mist systems. The fire protection objective terms for a water mist system are defined as:
- Fire extinguishment: A sharp reduction in heat release rate leading to complete elimination of any flaming or smouldering fire
- Fire suppression: A steady reduction in the heat release rate resulting in a lower controlled level of burning
- Fire control: Limitation of fire growth and protection of structure (by cooling of the objects, fire gases and/or by pre-wetting adjacent combustibles)
The following is a brief ‘Water Mist Checklist’ suggested by London Fire Brigade (LFB), which they use for reviewing the acceptability of a proposal when submitted to them for approval:
- Are design objectives clearly stated i.e. extinguishment/suppression/control – what trade off if any is being sought?
- Is relevant fire test data available/presented?
- System configuration compared to test data – note any deviations
- Water supply – type/duration, is this suitable given the stated design objective?System reliability and maintainability – they currently refer to sprinkler codes for advice on resilience requirements for life safety systems
- Other considerations such as extent of system, zoning and control valve locations, cause and effect, interactions with other systems
- Are appropriately qualified and experienced people undertaking the manufacture design, installation and maintenance of the system? (No third party certification schemes)
As mentioned, supporting evidence should be made available to demonstrate that water mist systems are fit for purpose. To meet this requirement fire tests are generally used in the industry.
As an alternative method to fire tests, mathematical modelling e.g. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) may also be utilised to demonstrate the performance of a water mist system, subject to a particular numerical model having been adequately validated for the intended water mist applications.
For instance, the numerical simulation of fire extinguishment is an extremely difficult task. None of the current CFD models has been extensively validated to predict fire extinguishment and this may be the case for some years to come. Therefore, the fire protection objectives for water mist systems should be clearly identified, before using mathematical modelling to demonstrate the performance of this form of suppression.
It is important that water mist systems are being designed and proved fit for purpose using suitable standards, fire demonstrations and performance tests. The use of mathematical modelling to demonstrate the performance of water mist systems is only acceptable subject to the validation of a numerical model used. Misunderstandings and lack of knowledge about water mist systems can lead to inappropriate application of these systems and therefore caution is strongly advised.
Lawrence Webster Forrest as specialist fire engineering and fire risk management consultants can provide clients with independent advice on water mist system manufacture, performance, suitability and appropriateness for individual circumstances, in particular for a project which requires water mist system as part of a holistic fire safety design package for buildings in the UK. For further information about LWF or to discuss water mist systems further, please contact Peter Gyere on 0208 668 8663.