Lawrence Webster Forrest (LWF), Fire Engineering and Fire Risk Management Consultants
Lawrence Webster Forrest (LWF), Fire Engineering and Fire Risk Management Consultants



Navigation

Client login
Forgotten password
Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook Subscribe to our blog

Lawrence Webster Forrest
Legion House
Lower Road
Kenley
Surrey
CR8 5NH

Tel: +44 (0)20 8668 8663 Fax: +44 (0)20 8668 8583
E-mail: fire@lwf.co.uk

Facilities Management & Fire Safety - Fire Safety Engineering & the Prescriptive Approach - Part 4

Posted by LWF: 08/11/2018 11:07

LWF’s blog series for those who work in Facilities Management or who have an interest in or responsibility for fire safety has been looking at the ideas behind fire safety engineering. In part 3, we looked at how the prescriptive approach was the one demanded by insurers until relatively recently when a more flexible approach was approved. In part 4, we will look at what is good about the prescriptive approach, as an alternative to fire engineered solutions.

While prescriptive methods of fire safety are used less frequently than in the past, in favour of an individually designed fire safety engineered solution, prescriptive approaches can provide a successful approach and in some circumstances, may be the best approach to a project. 

The rules of prescriptive fire safety are straightforward and allow a consistent approach.  It requires less complex understanding and assessment by enforcing authorities and therefore can often make for an easier process for the design team. The traditional way offers less risk in terms of liability and in terms of the potential for harm to any building occupants. This is not to say that prescriptive solutions are safer in and of themselves – a well-designed fire engineered solution can be safer, simply that a tried and tested method involves less risk, or at least, less risk-assessment.

It also follows, therefore, that a fire officer or insurance surveyor who has limited training in technical issues and no engineering qualification could more easily understand a prescriptive solution than a fire safety engineered one.
Many guides are based solely on prescriptive solutions and this is largely because the individual elements can be considered in isolation from each other with only minimal crossover between areas. For instance, when discussing travel distances to evacuate a building, prescriptive distances are easily quoted and do not have to be related often to other fire safety or fire prevention provision within the building. A fire engineered approach may sweep aside traditional travel distances because other facilities are in place, such as sprinklers or smoke extraction systems. A fire engineered solution should be particular and individual to the project in hand, whereas prescriptive figures can be compared across projects and buildings.

The vast majority of buildings are still designed as per prescriptive codes and most building work in terms of modification of existing buildings also follows those codes. This is not to say that fire engineers may not be involved with projects which are purely prescriptive in nature, they frequently are.

In part 5 of this series, LWF will look at some of the criticism of the prescriptive approach that has been heard in the last twenty or thirty years. In the meantime, if you have any queries about your own facilities or wish to discuss this blog series, please contact Peter Gyere in the first instance on 0208 668 8663.

Lawrence Webster Forrest is a fire engineering consultancy based in Surrey with over 25 years' experience, which provides a wide range of consultancy services to professionals involved in the design, development and construction and operation of buildings. 

While care has been taken to ensure that information contained in LWF's publications is true and correct at the time of publication, changes in circumstances after the time of publication may impact on the accuracy of this information.

Leave a reply

  *

  *

 


CAPTCHA Image

[ Change the image ]


*Required

Subscribe to our fire safety blogs

Bulletins
Email Format
* indicates required

FIRE SAFETY BLOGS

  • Fire Engineering Design and Risk Assessment - Firefighting - Part 14

    In LWFs fire safety engineering blog series for Architects and others in the building design business, we have begun to look at firefighting. In part 13, we began to look at how firefighting can be undertaken by the occupiers of a building if a fire starts. The use of portable fire extinguishers was discussed along with relevant training was discussed. In part 14, the provision of hose reels and the standards involved will be covered.

    Read more...

  • Fire Safety for Healthcare Premises - External Fire Spread - Part 48

    In LWF’s blog series for healthcare professionals, the aim is to give information on best practice of fire safety in hospitals and other healthcare premises. In part 47 of this series, LWF took a look at the use of sprinkler protection in healthcare venues and in part 48, we begin to discuss the potential for external fire spread and what precautions should be taken to avoid it.It should be borne in mind that we...

    Read more...

  • Facilities Management & Fire Safety - Fire Safety Engineering & the Prescriptive Approach - Part 5

    In LWFs blog series for those who work in facilities management or who have an interest in or responsibility for fire safety, we have been looking at the term ‘Fire Safety Engineering’ and what it involves. In part 4 of the series, we began to look at the differences between fire prevention and safety based on prescriptive codes and fire safety engineering. In part 5, we will continue from that point by looking at the...

    Read more...

  • Fire Engineering Design and Risk Assessment - Firefighting - Part 13

    In LWF’s fire engineering blog series for architects and others in the building design business, we began discussing firefighting. In part 12, an overview of the term and its meaning before looking at the method of firefighting, namely the strategy, tactics and operations of the Fire Service in the UK and equivalent organisations in other parts of the world. In part 13, we look at firefighting by occupiers of a building.Firefighting undertaken by occupiers...

    Read more...

  • Fire Safety for Healthcare Premises - Sprinklers - Part 47

    In LWF’s blog series for healthcare professionals, the aim is to give information on best practice of fire safety in hospitals and other healthcare premises. In part 46 of this series, we looked at the tank arrangement for sprinkler systems and how each pump should be arranged to draw water from either tank, so that any one tank or pump can be isolated. In part 47, we continue from that point on the subject of...

    Read more...

Case Studies

The Wohl Neuroscience Institute - Fire Safety, Strategy & Engineering
Key Facts: Client: King’s Clinical Neuroscience Institute Project Manager: MACE Ltd Designers: Devereux Architects/Allies and Morrison Approximate Size: 7,400m2 Description of the Project:...

Read more..

General Bulletins

Fire - The External Risk
When we consider fire safety, our focus is normally from within, what can we do to prevent the occurrence of fire and how we can limit its damage.  Whilst this is the correct stance to take, we m...

Read more..

Technical Bulletins

Evacuation Modelling - Factor in Human Behaviour
Evacuation of buildings can be analyzed in different ways. Approved Document B (ADB) which provides guidance on meeting the requirements of the England and Wales Building Regulations with regard to fi...

Read more..

Site map | Web development London